| Screaming Gophers|
|Place in Camp Drama|| Chris-napped|
Losers Who Lunch
|Place in Studio Drama|| Land of the Host|
|Friends||Eva, Lindsay, Sadie|
After arriving to the island in alongside her best friend, Sadie, only to be separated onto different teams, Katie makes quick friends with Lindsay. Katie soon after forms an alliance with Lindsay and Heather in The Hunter Games, though she is initially reluctant. This reluctance becomes stronger as Heather begins to act harsher and bossier towards the two, ordering them around like servants. In Chris-napped, Katie finally has enough of Heather's attitude and curses her out, resulting in her leaving the alliance and being eliminated that night. However later, in Losers Who Lunch, Katie returns to the island for a second chance at the competition. Now with a vendetta against Heather, she reunites with Lindsay and tries to befriend Geoff and Trent. But in the end, her efforts are in vain, and Katie is once again eliminated, due to annoying the other contestants. In Cut to the Case, Katie teams up with Sadie and Eva, and advances into Studio Drama.
- 1x01 - Confessions of a Teenage Drama Camper
- 1x02 - The Hunter Games
- 1x03 - Featherheads
- 1x04 - Forest Grumps
- 1x05 - Superstale
- 1x06 - Fool's Gold
- 1x07 - Your Goose Is Cooked
- 1x08 - Chris-napped
- 1x15 - Losers Who Lunch
- 1x22 - Camp Drama: Geoff vs. Gwen
- 1x23 - Cut to the Case
- 2x02 - It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad Monster
- 2x03 - Land of the Host
- 2x08 - Aftermath: Little Shop of Half-wits
- 2x15 - Aftermath: Wheel of Misfortune
- 2x16 - Studio Drama: Duncan vs. Lindsay
- 2x17 - Keeping Up with the Castmates
- She bears many similarities to Izzy.
- Both have been eliminated in a season only to return later on.
- Both have only competed in Camp Drama and Studio Drama.
- Both have been on the same-colored team in both seasons; Katie is on the Screaming Gophers and the Screaming Gaffers while Izzy is on the Killer Bass and Killer Grips.
- Both have also been eliminated three times without participating in three seasons.
|Eliminated from Camp Drama|
|Harold||Losers Who Lunch||Duncan|
|Eliminated from Studio Drama|
|N/A||Land of the Host||Noah|
|DJ | Ezekiel | Geoff | Gwen | Heather | Justin | Katie | Leshawna | Lindsay | Trent | Tyler|
|Courtney | Duncan | Geoff | Gwen | Harold | Heather | Katie | Noah|